Gartner Logo

Read the June 2022 Gartner Market Guide for Supplier Sustainability Applications

Learn more
SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift
How It Works Expand How It Works Menu
Product Overview Starter Assessments Standard Assessments Custom Assessments See A Demo
Solutions Expand Solutions Menu
Pricing
Industries Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Insights Expand Insights Menu
News & Blog News Blog
Resources Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us Expand About Us Menu
Get to Know us Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
Support
/
Login Let's Talk
How It Works
Solutions
Industries Expand Solutions Menu
Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues Expand Solutions Menu
Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Pricing
Insights
News & Blog Expand Insights Menu
News Blog
Resources Expand Insights Menu
Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us
Get to Know us Expand About Us Menu
Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
215 River Street Santa Cruz, CA 95060 415.935.1697 support@supplyshift.net Contact Form Support

Let's Talk

Industry Trends

ESG in the Public and Private Market: Putting the Supply Chain in Focus

06 / 03 / 2021
Alex Gershenson

SupplyShift's CEO Alex Gershenson shares his perspectives on private investment, ESG, and supply chains.

Share

The recent uptick of sustainability bonds from global companies like Wells Fargo, Bank of America, and most recently Amazon sends a strong market signal that focus on corporate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) is no longer just a trend – it’s the new business imperative. In 2021, most businesses understand that consumers are putting their dollars towards brands that align with their values, which often include sustainability and ESG. These consumers can spot greenwashing from a mile away and are demanding complete transparency and data from brands to back up their ESG claims. 

 

In the wake of COVID disruptions and the financial advantage earned by companies focusing on ESG despite major market uncertainty, investors are rapidly recognizing the strategic importance of these metrics as well. While there is a wide range of data covering the ESG initiatives of public companies, it’s becoming increasingly clear that privately held companies must also be able to tell their ESG story to secure funding and enter public markets. 

 

Let’s start by taking a look at how ESG, sustainability, and corporate finance have intersected over the years. 

 

The History of ESG and Corporate Finance 

 

In the early days, most businesses held a Green Vs. Gold mental model, where sustainability and profitability were seen as fundamentally at odds. ESG, in essence, was a luxury, or a “nice to have.” 

 

However, companies soon began to realize that incorporating ESG into their business models was not only a necessary cost of satisfying the modern customer and staying off the radar of prominent environmental NGOs, but brought financial rewards as well. In the last 10 years especially, the rise of the conscious consumer has spurred companies to live up to higher ethical and environmental standards. In fact, nearly 70% of consumers in North America think it’s important for a brand to be sustainable. What’s more, 80% want to know the origin of their products, and 69% of these consumers would pay a premium for brands that readily provide this kind of transparency. 

 

At the same time, pressure from NGOs was on the rise. Who could forget the Barbie deforestation scandal of 2011, when Greenpeace discovered that toy manufacturer Mattel was sourcing packaging material from a supplier clearing rainforests from critical wildlife areas. 

 

Today, while the Green Vs. Gold mental model still holds true for some, there is a significant amount of data that conclusively demonstrates that sustainability and profitability are tightly correlated. For example, NYU Stern’s Center for Sustainable Business recently found that 50% of growth in CPGs from 2013 to 2018 came from products marketed with sustainability. Similarly, Unilever’s purpose-led, Sustainable Living Brands grew 69% faster than the rest of the business in 2018. 

 

Just as Van Halen’s brown M&Ms Rider has become a great metaphor for proxy measures that alert you in advance to poor management practices, companies that focus on ESG are typically in a better place operationally and financially. A great trick to assess the organizational maturity of a company is to ask about their greenhouse gas (GHG) footprint: a company that has proper financial and operational controls in place will be in a far better position to monitor its ESG metrics.  

 

Corporate ESG Reporting Today 

 

As investors and shareholders demand more accountability, we are beginning to see ESG metrics more tightly integrated into corporate reporting metrics. This trend will certainly become more prevalent in the coming years as investors continue to demand ESG accountability as a standard indicator of corporate performance and risk, and as fund managers are prioritizing ESG as a key metric for fund inclusion for public companies. 

 

ESG accountability is closely linked to the concept of “responsible supply chains.” After all, the greatest ESG impacts are found not in direct operations but in the supply chain. When it comes to accountability, prioritizing supply chain ESG performance will be fundamental to meeting the demands of shareholders and investors. There is momentum building around this concept as well. The term “responsible supply chains” did not emerge until the late 2010s but became more mainstream in 2020 with the havoc wreaked by COVID-19. Deloitte’s 10th Annual Chief Procurement Officer Survey mirrors this shift in priorities. Corporate social responsibility (CSR) saw the largest increase of any priority among CPOs (22% increase over 2019). 

 

When it comes to “responsible supply chain management,” ESG is now regularly being discussed at the board level. By 2023 or 2024, we can expect that the concept of responsible supply chains will be integrated into overall “supply chain management” as a normalized best practice. In other words, “responsible supply chains” will no longer just be a trend but rather a core priority amongst procurement teams.  

 

Investment and ESG in the Public and Private Market

 

In the early days, similar to corporate ESG management, public and private impact investing was recognized primarily for its environmental and social benefits, with a secondary focus on financial returns.   

 

The status quo began to shift in the late 2010s with the rise of the sustainable Exchange Traded Fund (ETF), or the “ESG ETF.” Around this time, markets began to notice that companies prioritizing sustainability were enjoying increased financial performance and profitability alongside brand reputation. 

 

However, corporate sustainability was really brought into focus in 2020. The first major signal came even before the official start of the pandemic, in January of 2020 with the annual Blackrock CEO letter. Larry Fink fired a major warning shot by stating that Blackrock would now be paying full attention to corporate sustainability metrics, since he saw them as part of overall business viability and financial success. He reiterated that commitment at the end of March of 2020, as the pandemic was ravaging Europe and the US. 

 

In many ways, he was eerily prescient. Amid the global COVID-19 pandemic, ESG funds outperformed non-ESG funds by a staggering 4.3%. This was the largest difference in performance recorded since 2004. In 2020, sustainable ETFs also saw record inflows of $75 billion, triple those seen in 2019. 

 

These trends will undoubtedly continue to rise in the near future. Within the next 5 years alone, it is projected that a majority of all European mutual fund assets will be tied to ESG factors. It’s safe to say that ESG investing is shaping up to be the most significant money managing development since the creation of the ETF.  

 

What does this mean for you and your business? Making ESG commitments gets investors excited, and it’s becoming abundantly clear that shareholders are rewarding companies that take public steps to reduce their climate impact. 

 

The Future of ESG 

 

Similar to the notion of responsible supply chains, the concept of ESG will disappear as a “nice to have” in the not-so-distant future. Instead, it will become a standard reporting KPI alongside revenue, COGS, and EBITDA. 

 

Yet, there are a few hurdles to overcome. One challenge is the lack of standardized ESG reporting – currently, there are no uniform standards for sustainability and social responsibility KPIs. Much remains to be seen on whether sustainability measurement and reporting standards can serve not only companies and investors, but also people and planet. 

 

Encouragingly, industry groups are beginning to come together and create industry-relevant standards, and it’s likely that carbon will become one of the few cross-industry benchmarks. As considerations of climate impact and risk continue to drive investor concern, we’re seeing carbon take the spotlight. Shareholders are now using their leverage and voting power to increase executives’ ESG accountability, meaning that global brands can no longer afford to drag their feet on the climate issue. 

 

Similar alliances are taking shape among private equity investors, too. One such example is the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative, an international group of asset managers supporting ESG investing aligned with the goal of reaching net zero emissions by 2050. To date, this initiative already has 87 signatories and $37 trillion assets under management. 

 

In this day and age, ESG is clearly a critical component of corporate performance in the public market. One additional challenge for private market companies is that there are very few ESG solutions and data collection systems available. But this does not make ESG reporting any less important. 

 

LPs of private equity firms care more about ESG than ever before. When you’re raising your next round of funds, you must be able to tell the ESG story of your entire value chain. Without your ESG story in hand, you may even lose access to certain LPs, as some have ESG portfolio mandates. The same is true for brands looking to go public. Companies entering the public market need to have a plan for ESG performance that is fully integrated into overall corporate reporting.

 

Whether you’re a business reporting sustainability KPIs or a private equity firm looking to create a more future-proof portfolio, the business case for ESG is undeniable. Yet the key driver (or inhibitor) of your company or portfolio’s ESG performance is the supply chain.

 

Keep an eye out for an exciting new product launch in the coming weeks that will help investors unlock ESG insights from portfolio companies and their supply chains.  At SupplyShift, we are proud to be providing tools for businesses, and soon investors, that enable real progress in supply chain sustainability and ESG investment.

Share
Alex Gershenson
Connect on LinkedIn

Alex received his doctorate in Environmental Studies from UC Santa Cruz, with a focus on climate science and policy. Alex is a well-known expert in responsible sourcing, sustainability, carbon accounting, environmental policy, and economics. Alex is a published author and a frequent speaker at conferences that focus on responsible sourcing and supply chain management. Prior to starting SupplyShift, Alex was a professor of Policy and Science at San Jose State University and a co-founder of an environmental consulting firm that focused on climate and carbon consulting for enterprise and government clients.

author portrait

Related Posts

Prev Slide
Labor & Human Rights
Complying with the UFLPA: How to Detect ..
Read More
Complying with the UFLPA: How to Detect Forced Labor in Your Supply Chain
Industry Trends
What Does Supplier Collaboration Mean fo..
Read More
What Does Supplier Collaboration Mean for Sustainability?
Deforestation
Addressing Deforestation in the Supply C..
Read More
Addressing Deforestation in the Supply Chain
Industry Trends
What To Do About Low Sustainability Perf..
Read More
What To Do About Low Sustainability Performers
Labor & Human Rights
Addressing Labor Issues in the Supply Ch..
Read More
Addressing Labor Issues in the Supply Chain
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Supply Chain Mapping – Why and How?
Read More
Supply Chain Mapping – Why and How?
Industry Trends,Marketing
Beyond Annual Reports: Three Ways to Lev..
Read More
Beyond Annual Reports: Three Ways to Leverage Supplier Sustainability Information for Your Business
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Creating Your Roadmap for Supplier Susta..
Read More
Creating Your Roadmap for Supplier Sustainability Improvement
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Summit ’21 – Five Key Learni..
Read More
Summit ’21 – Five Key Learnings for your Supply Chain Sustainability Journey
Supply Chain Management
Simplifying Sustainability for Procureme..
Read More
Simplifying Sustainability for Procurement
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sust..
Read More
Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sustainability
Supply Chain Management
How Suppliers Demonstrate Best Practices..
Read More
How Suppliers Demonstrate Best Practices to Buyers
Supply Chain Management
How Remote Assessments Can Reduce Audit ..
Read More
How Remote Assessments Can Reduce Audit Costs
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Engagement Best Practices ̵..
Read More
Supplier Engagement Best Practices – Key Takeaways From Our Webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Tackling Plastics and Packaging in Suppl..
Read More
Tackling Plastics and Packaging in Supply Chains
Supply Chain Management
Best Practices for Sending Supplier Sust..
Read More
Best Practices for Sending Supplier Sustainability Assessments
Supply Chain Management
Maximizing Supplier Participation in Sus..
Read More
Maximizing Supplier Participation in Sustainability Reporting
Supply Chain Management
Roadmap of Industry Groups – Your Comp..
Read More
Roadmap of Industry Groups – Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sustainability Collaboration
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusi..
Read More
Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Your Supply Chain
Supply Chain Management
How to Identify Your Supply Chain Sustai..
Read More
How to Identify Your Supply Chain Sustainability Risks and Opportunities
Supply Chain Management
How to Approach Multi-Tier Supplier Asse..
Read More
How to Approach Multi-Tier Supplier Assessments
Supply Chain Management
What is Multi-Tier and Why to Do It
Read More
What is Multi-Tier and Why to Do It
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How to Set Corporate Goals for Supply Ch..
Read More
How to Set Corporate Goals for Supply Chain ESG
Industry Trends
How Industry Group Collaboration Drives ..
Read More
How Industry Group Collaboration Drives Sustainability Improvement
Industry Trends
ESG in the Public and Private Market: Pu..
Read More
ESG in the Public and Private Market: Putting the Supply Chain in Focus
Climate,Industry Trends
Supply Chain Emissions 2021 – Key ..
Read More
Supply Chain Emissions 2021 – Key Takeaways from our Webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Why Sustainable Supply Chains?
Read More
Why Sustainable Supply Chains?
Climate,Industry Trends
The Importance of Measuring Scope 3 Supp..
Read More
The Importance of Measuring Scope 3 Supply Chain Emissions and How to Get Started
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Active Vs. Passive Supplier Sustainabili..
Read More
Active Vs. Passive Supplier Sustainability Assessments
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Supplier Sustainability Assessment ─ W..
Read More
Supplier Sustainability Assessment ─ Where Do I Start?
Industry Trends,Labor & Human Rights
Forced labor in cotton supply chains ─..
Read More
Forced labor in cotton supply chains ─ Key takeaways from our webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Three Ways Procurement Can Drive Sustain..
Read More
Three Ways Procurement Can Drive Sustainability Through the Supply Chain
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How to prepare for a transparent supply ..
Read More
How to prepare for a transparent supply chain in 2021
Climate,Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
The emerging shape of recovery
Read More
The emerging shape of recovery
Climate,Industry Trends
Supply chain emissions: what challenges ..
Read More
Supply chain emissions: what challenges lie ahead?
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Transparency is the first step to securi..
Read More
Transparency is the first step to securing global supply chains
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How standardization advances supply chai..
Read More
How standardization advances supply chain responsibility
Responsible Holidays
Retail sustainability during the holiday..
Read More
Retail sustainability during the holidays
Climate
Global Climate Strike and how to achieve..
Read More
Global Climate Strike and how to achieve your Science-Based Targets
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Blockchain for Responsible Sourcing – ..
Read More
Blockchain for Responsible Sourcing – Where Does It Fit?
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
Worker Insights to Drive Action: How to ..
Read More
Worker Insights to Drive Action: How to Operationalize Worker Voice Using Technology
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
When Worker Voice is Next on the Agenda
Read More
When Worker Voice is Next on the Agenda
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
When Worker Voice is Only a Whisper
Read More
When Worker Voice is Only a Whisper
Industry Trends,Labor & Human Rights
How Businesses Can Address Modern Slaver..
Read More
How Businesses Can Address Modern Slavery in Supply Chains
Industry Trends,Marketing
The Sustainable CMO: 3 Values for Market..
Read More
The Sustainable CMO: 3 Values for Marketing Leadership
Responsible Holidays
Good News for Holiday Coffee Lovers — ..
Read More
Good News for Holiday Coffee Lovers — More Investment in Responsible Coffee Supply Chains
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
You Can’t ‘Contract Away’ Supply C..
Read More
You Can’t ‘Contract Away’ Supply Chain Problems
Responsible Holidays
Is Your Halloween Candy Responsibly Sour..
Read More
Is Your Halloween Candy Responsibly Sourced?
Supply Chain Management
Moving Beyond Spreadsheets for Responsib..
Read More
Moving Beyond Spreadsheets for Responsible Supply Chains
Deforestation,Supply Chain Management
Effective Traceability for Responsible P..
Read More
Effective Traceability for Responsible Pulp, Paper, & Packaging
Supply Chain Management
4 Elements of a Successful Supply Chain ..
Read More
4 Elements of a Successful Supply Chain Transparency Strategy
Supply Chain Management
From the Farmer to the Foil: The Cacao S..
Read More
From the Farmer to the Foil: The Cacao Supply Chain Challenge
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Responsible sourcing as part of corporat..
Read More
Responsible sourcing as part of corporate governance
Deforestation,Responsible Holidays
What’s in a Box: Creating More Respons..
Read More
What’s in a Box: Creating More Responsible Holidays!
Next Slide
SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift
Terms of Use
/
Privacy Policy
Stay in the Know
How It Works
Product Overview Starter Assessments Standard Assessments Custom Assessments See A Demo
Solutions
Industries
Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues
Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Pricing
Insights
News Blog
Resources
Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us
Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
Contact
215 River Street Santa Cruz, CA 95060 415.935.1697 +44 2045 251266 support@supplyshift.net Contact Form Support
All materials © SupplyShift 2022
/
All rights reserved
/
Designed by Sleepless