Gartner Logo

Read the June 2022 Gartner Market Guide for Supplier Sustainability Applications

Learn more
SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift
How It Works Expand How It Works Menu
How it Works Starter Assessments Standard Assessments Custom Assessments
Solutions Expand Solutions Menu
Industries Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Insights Expand Insights Menu
News & Blog News Blog
Resources Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us Expand About Us Menu
Get to Know us Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
Support
/
Login Let's Talk
How It Works
Solutions
Industries Expand Solutions Menu
Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues Expand Solutions Menu
Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Insights
News & Blog Expand Insights Menu
News Blog
Resources Expand Insights Menu
Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us
Get to Know us Expand About Us Menu
Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
215 River Street Santa Cruz, CA 95060 415.935.1697 support@supplyshift.net Contact Form Support

Let's Talk

Industry Trends, Marketing

Beyond Annual Reports: Three Ways to Leverage Supplier Sustainability Information for Your Business

11 / 29 / 2021
Matt Gottron
Share

In recent years, companies have come under increasing scrutiny from customers, employees, investors, governments, and NGOs. What do they want? For companies to demonstrate environmental stewardship and get proactive on social issues.

 

As this scrutiny mounts, companies and countries worldwide are making tremendous strides to tackle the sustainability agenda, with organizations such as the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) and industry-accepted pledges like the Paris Accord providing much needed frameworks and leadership.

 

As the world strives to meet these targets, many companies are using annual sustainability reports as the primary mechanism of communicating their achievements. These reports highlight a company’s strong points and low points and can be useful summaries of sustainability progress overall. However, sustainability reports aren’t enough in and of themselves.

 

In this blog we outline some ideas on how organizations can utilize supplier sustainability information beyond annual reports to the advantage of their business.

 

The Sustainability Reporting Problem

 

With so many companies producing annual reports, it’s almost endemic; it’s a corporate sustainability practice that has existed ever since the drive for sustainability began. Ninety percent of companies in the S&P 500 produce corporate sustainability reports, as well as 65% of the Russell 1000 index.

 

For two decades, leading voices in industry and organizations have been pressuring companies to become more transparent—and, subsequently, responsible—about the damage they’re doing to the ecosystems they work within. Kenneth Pucker, a senior lecturer at Tufts University, suggests that endorsers of annual reports believed that four key things would happen if companies publicly reported their sustainability performance statistics:

 

  1. The ESG performance of individual companies would improve.
  2. Gradually, the corporate world would see that better sustainability performance equates to better returns.
  3. Companies with stronger sustainability performance would see their revenue rise due to both consumers and investors choosing their products and services, putting pressure on those that are slow on the uptake of sustainable norms.
  4. The corporate world would accept the evolving efforts to monitor companies’ social and environmental impact, leading to more rigorous and accurate practices.

 

Unfortunately, the results are mixed, and the assumed results of annual reports were pretty far off the mark.

 

Pucker suggests that the idea of reporting has been oversold by the powers that be. When it comes to corporate sustainability reporting, the world as a whole has confused output with impact, and the evidence is clear. Across the two decades, Scope 1-3 GHG emissions have risen, our impact on the environment has worsened, social inequality is on the rise—even in the supposedly “leading” western nations—and the wealth disparity between western and eastern countries has grown exponentially.

 

Evidently, reporting is not representative of progress when it comes to sustainability.

 

Even in the companies that seem most impressively sustainable, the case is often the opposite. Unfortunately, greenwashing is rampant in annual reports, and companies tend only to share what they want people to hear. The fashion industry is an excellent example of this. Fashion houses are quick to highlight their recycled materials, vegan-friendly “leathers,” and eco-friendly tendencies but choose to omit the manufacturing and shipping process they depend on to produce the apparel, where more than 87% of GHG emissions come from.

 

Unfortunately, any good marketing effort will, in some way, exploit the sentimentality of others. In the case of the fashion industry, companies highlight their efforts to use more sustainable materials because it will resonate strongly with consumers. However, that removes focus from the manufacturing side of the industry and doesn’t hold the industry accountable for its use of fossil fuels across global supply chains.

 

“Measurement is often nonstandard, incomplete, imprecise, and misleading. And headlines touting new milestones in disclosure and socially responsible investment are often just fanciful “greenwishing” (in the coinage of Duncan Austin, a former ESG investment manager). Worse yet, the focus on reporting may actually be an obstacle to progress—consuming bandwidth, exaggerating gains, and distracting from the very real need for changes in mindsets, regulation, and corporate behavior.” ─ Kenneth P. Pucker

 

So, understanding that reports can’t be an end in and of themselves, what should a company be doing with supplier sustainability information? Shifting the focus from reporting to action is the best way forward.

 

Three Actionable Ways to Leverage Supplier Sustainability Information

 

While annual reports might be a great way to put a bow on your sustainability work across the year, consider implementing these strategies as a way to get more mileage out of your data.

 

1. Build authentic product positioning centered around supply chain sustainability
  • Start including supplier sustainability stories as components of your brand storytelling. This is a great way to build authenticity into your products, showcasing exactly how your company is driving genuine impact and therefore taking action where it counts—the supply chain.
  • Include updates on supply chain sustainability and supplier shout-outs in your promotional materials to communicate why supply chain sustainability is important, how your company is doing, and your ambitions.
  • Share your transparency story online to show your customers where your products come from.

 

For example, Ford Motor Company has long been labeled one of America’s most iconic employers – and polluters. Ford pivoted to include sustainability as part of their brand story, utilizing paint fumes as fuel and using sustainable fabrics in its vehicles. By 2035, Ford expects to power all of its plants on renewable energy.

 

2. To drive improvement with your suppliers
  • Create supplier benchmarking reports and share them back with suppliers. Remember that supplier engagement is not a one-way street—giving your suppliers something valuable encourages more participation and motivates improvement.
  • Host seminars with your suppliers to share what you’ve found in a collaborative environment.
  • Use data to find new engagement opportunities – does a high emitting supplier need support to reduce their carbon footprint? Does a supplier with inadequate policies around labor need hands-on assistance to update their policies? Find the highest impact opportunities to partner with suppliers and execute on them.

 

Nike is a good example of a company bringing visibility to sub-tier suppliers and their practices. After coming under fire in the ‘90s, Nike has focused on achieving gender equity, worker wellbeing in factories, and scrutinizing and improving environmental responsibility.

 

3. Integrate supplier sustainability into your procurement processes
  • Include supplier scorecard data in performance reviews and contracts.
  • Consider giving high-scoring suppliers more favorable terms—treat it as a reward for meeting your standards.
  • Use supplier data in your procurement processes to help normalize responsible sourcing. It can also help support an authentically sustainable brand and culture.

 

Since as early as 2013 Best Buy has been integrating sustainability into its procurement processes. Best Buy is continuously ranked in the top list of sustainable companies and now operates America’s largest e-recycling program.

 

Wrapping It Up

 

When it comes to high-leverage interventions that can seriously make a difference, it’s a hard ask for most companies. A lot of the necessary changes would involve changes to the governance of companies and the rules by which the corporate world plays.

 

That said, by aligning your company with science-based goals, you’re on the promising path of improvement. However, if companies and nations truly intend to meet targets set out by SBTi, the Paris Accord, and the United Nations, the corporate world will have to step up its game and take a much more aggressive approach to sustainability.

 

Annual reports are a great way to summarize work, but the tendency for them to gloss over problems and only focus on the positive is highly problematic. Companies need to start including more action-oriented approaches to sustainability, rather than sharing just for the sake of sharing.

Share
Matt Gottron
Connect on LinkedIn

Matt is the Senior Marketing Manager for SupplyShift, where he oversees SupplyShift’s strategic marketing initiatives and maintains a deep understanding of the challenges businesses face in their approach to supply chain sustainability. Matt is passionate about transparency and strives to bring useful and actionable information to companies looking to accelerate their sustainable supply chain journeys.

author portrait

Related Posts

Prev Slide
Industry Trends
What Does Supplier Collaboration Mean fo..
Read More
What Does Supplier Collaboration Mean for Sustainability?
Deforestation
Addressing Deforestation in the Supply C..
Read More
Addressing Deforestation in the Supply Chain
Industry Trends
What To Do About Low Sustainability Perf..
Read More
What To Do About Low Sustainability Performers
Labor & Human Rights
Addressing Labor Issues in the Supply Ch..
Read More
Addressing Labor Issues in the Supply Chain
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Supply Chain Mapping – Why and How?
Read More
Supply Chain Mapping – Why and How?
Industry Trends,Marketing
Beyond Annual Reports: Three Ways to Lev..
Read More
Beyond Annual Reports: Three Ways to Leverage Supplier Sustainability Information for Your Business
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Creating Your Roadmap for Supplier Susta..
Read More
Creating Your Roadmap for Supplier Sustainability Improvement
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Summit ’21 – Five Key Learni..
Read More
Summit ’21 – Five Key Learnings for your Supply Chain Sustainability Journey
Supply Chain Management
Simplifying Sustainability for Procureme..
Read More
Simplifying Sustainability for Procurement
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sust..
Read More
Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sustainability
Supply Chain Management
How Suppliers Demonstrate Best Practices..
Read More
How Suppliers Demonstrate Best Practices to Buyers
Supply Chain Management
How Remote Assessments Can Reduce Audit ..
Read More
How Remote Assessments Can Reduce Audit Costs
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Engagement Best Practices ̵..
Read More
Supplier Engagement Best Practices – Key Takeaways From Our Webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Tackling Plastics and Packaging in Suppl..
Read More
Tackling Plastics and Packaging in Supply Chains
Supply Chain Management
Best Practices for Sending Supplier Sust..
Read More
Best Practices for Sending Supplier Sustainability Assessments
Supply Chain Management
Maximizing Supplier Participation in Sus..
Read More
Maximizing Supplier Participation in Sustainability Reporting
Supply Chain Management
Roadmap of Industry Groups – Your Comp..
Read More
Roadmap of Industry Groups – Your Complete Guide to Supply Chain Sustainability Collaboration
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusi..
Read More
Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Your Supply Chain
Supply Chain Management
How to Identify Your Supply Chain Sustai..
Read More
How to Identify Your Supply Chain Sustainability Risks and Opportunities
Supply Chain Management
How to Approach Multi-Tier Supplier Asse..
Read More
How to Approach Multi-Tier Supplier Assessments
Supply Chain Management
What is Multi-Tier and Why to Do It
Read More
What is Multi-Tier and Why to Do It
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How to Set Corporate Goals for Supply Ch..
Read More
How to Set Corporate Goals for Supply Chain ESG
Industry Trends
How Industry Group Collaboration Drives ..
Read More
How Industry Group Collaboration Drives Sustainability Improvement
Industry Trends
ESG in the Public and Private Market: Pu..
Read More
ESG in the Public and Private Market: Putting the Supply Chain in Focus
Climate,Industry Trends
Supply Chain Emissions 2021 – Key ..
Read More
Supply Chain Emissions 2021 – Key Takeaways from our Webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Why Sustainable Supply Chains?
Read More
Why Sustainable Supply Chains?
Climate,Industry Trends
The Importance of Measuring Scope 3 Supp..
Read More
The Importance of Measuring Scope 3 Supply Chain Emissions and How to Get Started
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Active Vs. Passive Supplier Sustainabili..
Read More
Active Vs. Passive Supplier Sustainability Assessments
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Supplier Sustainability Assessment ─ W..
Read More
Supplier Sustainability Assessment ─ Where Do I Start?
Industry Trends,Labor & Human Rights
Forced labor in cotton supply chains ─..
Read More
Forced labor in cotton supply chains ─ Key takeaways from our webinar
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Three Ways Procurement Can Drive Sustain..
Read More
Three Ways Procurement Can Drive Sustainability Through the Supply Chain
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How to prepare for a transparent supply ..
Read More
How to prepare for a transparent supply chain in 2021
Climate,Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
The emerging shape of recovery
Read More
The emerging shape of recovery
Climate,Industry Trends
Supply chain emissions: what challenges ..
Read More
Supply chain emissions: what challenges lie ahead?
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Transparency is the first step to securi..
Read More
Transparency is the first step to securing global supply chains
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
How standardization advances supply chai..
Read More
How standardization advances supply chain responsibility
Responsible Holidays
Retail sustainability during the holiday..
Read More
Retail sustainability during the holidays
Climate
Global Climate Strike and how to achieve..
Read More
Global Climate Strike and how to achieve your Science-Based Targets
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Blockchain for Responsible Sourcing – ..
Read More
Blockchain for Responsible Sourcing – Where Does It Fit?
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
Worker Insights to Drive Action: How to ..
Read More
Worker Insights to Drive Action: How to Operationalize Worker Voice Using Technology
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
When Worker Voice is Next on the Agenda
Read More
When Worker Voice is Next on the Agenda
Labor & Human Rights,Supply Chain Management
When Worker Voice is Only a Whisper
Read More
When Worker Voice is Only a Whisper
Industry Trends,Labor & Human Rights
How Businesses Can Address Modern Slaver..
Read More
How Businesses Can Address Modern Slavery in Supply Chains
Industry Trends,Marketing
The Sustainable CMO: 3 Values for Market..
Read More
The Sustainable CMO: 3 Values for Marketing Leadership
Responsible Holidays
Good News for Holiday Coffee Lovers — ..
Read More
Good News for Holiday Coffee Lovers — More Investment in Responsible Coffee Supply Chains
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
You Can’t ‘Contract Away’ Supply C..
Read More
You Can’t ‘Contract Away’ Supply Chain Problems
Responsible Holidays
Is Your Halloween Candy Responsibly Sour..
Read More
Is Your Halloween Candy Responsibly Sourced?
Supply Chain Management
Moving Beyond Spreadsheets for Responsib..
Read More
Moving Beyond Spreadsheets for Responsible Supply Chains
Deforestation,Supply Chain Management
Effective Traceability for Responsible P..
Read More
Effective Traceability for Responsible Pulp, Paper, & Packaging
Supply Chain Management
4 Elements of a Successful Supply Chain ..
Read More
4 Elements of a Successful Supply Chain Transparency Strategy
Supply Chain Management
From the Farmer to the Foil: The Cacao S..
Read More
From the Farmer to the Foil: The Cacao Supply Chain Challenge
Industry Trends,Supply Chain Management
Responsible sourcing as part of corporat..
Read More
Responsible sourcing as part of corporate governance
Deforestation,Responsible Holidays
What’s in a Box: Creating More Respons..
Read More
What’s in a Box: Creating More Responsible Holidays!
Next Slide
SupplyShift Logo SupplyShift
Terms of Use
/
Privacy Policy
Stay in the Know
How It Works
How it Works Starter Assessments Standard Assessments Custom Assessments
Solutions
Industries
Beauty & Personal Care High Tech & Electronics Pharmaceuticals Food & Beverage Apparel Retail
Issues
Climate Change Impact ESG Investing Modern Slavery COVID-19 Deforestation Diversity Plastics
Insights
News Blog
Resources
Analyst Report Success Stories Webinars White Papers
About Us
Alliances Our Mission & Story Our Values and Team Careers Contact Us
Contact
215 River Street Santa Cruz, CA 95060 415.935.1697 +44 2045 251266 support@supplyshift.net Contact Form Support
All materials © SupplyShift 2022
/
All rights reserved
/
Designed by Sleepless